Growing up, my favorite genre was mystery – especially a
good “who done it?” As we get ready for our #bookbootcamp Twitter chat, I spent
some time reviewing the OLD stuff I grew up on.
Having done that, I have a better idea of what I am looking for when I
decide a middle grade mystery is either good or not so good.
The earliest mysteries I remember reading were Donald
Sobol’s Encyclopedia Brown books, the
first of which was published in 1963. I
loved the short story format, and the fact that if you were really paying
attention, you could solve the mystery with Encyclopedia. When I was reading The Three Investigator series, it had just started, 1968. The series ran through 1987 with 44 titles.
If you are my age and grew up reading mystery series in
school, you have reason to thank a literary syndicate, Stratemeyer Syndicate. Originally founded in 1909 by Edward
Stratemeyer, the syndicate was noted for formulaic,
ghost-written, and wildly popular mystery and adventure series including Nancy
Drew, Trixie Belden, Cherry Ames, The Bobbsey Twins, and The Hardy Boys. Like most kids, I grew up not knowing that the
authors Carolyn Keene, Laura Lee Hope, and F. W. Dixon were pseudonyms.
This week, I re-read the first Nancy Drew mystery, The Secret of the Old Clock. Anachronisms that I did not notice in the
1960’s grabbed my attention. For example, Nancy wears gloves when she drives in her
convertible, many of the homes she visits don’t have phones, and why wouldn’t a
girl as smart as she is be heading for college? The author refers to Nancy over and over as "the young sleuth." Of course, none of these details were noticed when I read the book in elementary school.
In
high school, I read
classic mysteries such as Sherlock Holmes and added several “Golden Age”of mystery writing authors to my favorites list, including Agatha
Christie and Dorothy Sayers. The creepiest murder mystery I ever read was nonfiction, In Cold Blood (1965) by Truman Capote. It terrified me with the randomness of the murders.
I have a few criteria that I
look for in a good mystery:
- I want a crime – murder, theft, kidnapping, poison pen letters, I don’t care, but at the end of the book I want to be able to state the conflict as a crime that was committed, and the resolution as the solution to the crime.
- I want enough clues that I can make a reasonable guess at the solution, but don’t give it away too early.
- I am OK with last minute revelations, “Yes! It is true that I was the nanny of the murdered child and that makes me an obvious suspect had you only known that small fact from the beginning!”
- I want the mystery solved at the end. Don’t leave me guessing.
Stratemeyer Syndicate. (2001). In The Cambridge Guide to
Children's Books in English. Retrieved from
http://www.credoreference.com/entry/childbooks/stratemeyer_syndicate
I just read The Raven Boys and The Dream Thieves two excellent books. They are mysteries, but not in a traditional way. They are also YA, but I think they would certainly be read by middle school students.
ReplyDeleteI just read The Raven Boys and The Dream Thieves two excellent books. They are mysteries, but not in a traditional way. They are also YA, but I think they would certainly be read by middle school students.
ReplyDelete